No, You Cannot Be Catholic AND Pro-RH Bill

Mga Katoliko Dagsa Sa Mga Simbahan Ngayong Unang Araw ng Kwaresma

So many flocked to Church on Ash Wednesday…

How many truly understand what Ash Wednesday is? How many of them understand what being a real, dyed-in-the-wool Catholic is? How many of them openly support the Reproductive Health Bill? How many of these people go and get their ashes and then leave the Church to go worship at the altar of “Choice”?

Can one be Catholic and pro-RH bill? Despite the lies perpetrated by RH Bill supporters, the answer is NO, you cannot be Catholic and pro-RH bill. “pro-RH bill Catholic” is an oxymoron. There is no such thing. Either these people are terribly misguided and don’t have a full appreciation of what Scripture and Tradition have taught from the beginning, OR they are deliberately misinterpreting what “Catholic” is.

Catholic means you mold yourself to conform to God’s will, not ask God to conform His will to yours, or pretend that God’s will matches yours. God’s Fifth Commandment is clear and unambiguous: Thou Shalt Not Kill. God is the Author of all life, and none of us have the right to end — on a whim — what He has authored. You can argue ’til the end of the time that a fetus is merely a clump of cells. Reason tells us — not religion, not morality — that this clump of cells is the beginning of life. It does not develop into a tumor or a cyst. The conclusion is the same no matter how much we try to twist the facts: the moment of conception means NEW LIFE. And since some contraceptives act AFTER fertilization, there is always the risk that you aren’t just preventing a pregnancy, you’re ENDING a pregnancy. Do you really want that on your conscience? If your conscience is well-formed, you won’t.

Catholic means you agree with and obey the Church’s teachings. From the Catechism of the Catholic Church:

2270 Human life must be respected and protected absolutely from the moment of conception. From the first moment of his existence, a human being must be recognized as having the rights of a person—among which is the inviolable right of every innocent being to life.

Before I formed you in the womb I knew you, and before you were born I consecrated you.
My frame was not hidden from you, when I was being made in secret, intricately wrought in the depths of the earth.

2271 Since the first century the Church has affirmed the moral evil of every procured abortion. This teaching has not changed and remains unchangeable. Direct abortion, that is to say, abortion willed either as an end or a means, is gravely contrary to the moral law:

You shall not kill the embryo by abortion and shall not cause the newborn to perish.

God, the Lord of life, has entrusted to men the noble mission of safeguarding life, and men must carry it out in a manner worthy of themselves. Life must be protected with the utmost care from the moment of conception: abortion and infanticide are abominable crimes.

Catholic means you take the time to understand what CHOICE really means and why you need to fight for REAL choices. It is an irony that many women who undergo abortions do so precisely because they feel THEY HAVE NO CHOICE. And if what you’re fighting for is that women get to choose what they do even if it means the death of another human being, that’s no different from saying “I am against murder, but I fully support someone’s CHOICE to kill another human being.”

In Archbishop Carlson’s words:

People who are casual about the sin of abortion and who choose to view it as a political issue rather than the serious moral issue that it is are guilty of violating the Fifth Commandment. That’s why the Church asks those who maintain this position not to receive holy Communion. We are not being mean or judgmental, we are simply acknowledging the fact that such a stance is objectively and seriously sinful and is radically inconsistent with the Christian way of life.

Catholic means you respect EVERYONE’S choice, not just your own. That includes people who choose to exercise their properly-formed consciences and go against what’s popular or even what’s legislated. For instance, abortion may be legal, as in the United States, but that doesn’t make it right. Abortion is still an intrinsically evil, morally-depraved act. Since the RH bill has conditional conscience protection clauses, it still effectively discriminates against those who for one reason or another may choose to not provide contraception or abortion services.

SEC. 28. Prohibited Acts. – The following acts are prohibited: Any healthcare service provider, whether public or private, who shall:

  1. Knowingly withhold information or restrict the dissemination thereof, and/or intentionally provide incorrect information regarding programs and services on reproductive health, including the right to informed choice and access to a full range of legal, medically-safe and effective family planning methods
  2. Refuse to perform legal and medically-safe reproductive health procedures on any person of legal age on the ground of lack of third party consent or authorization. In case of married persons, the mutual consent of the spouses shall be preferred. However in case of disagreement, the decision of the one undergoing the procedure shall prevail. In the case of abused minors where parents and/or other family members are the respondent, accused or convicted perpetrators as certified by the proper prosecutorial office or court, no prior parental consent shall be necessary; and
  3. Refuse to extend health care services and information on account of the person’s marital status, gender, sexual orientation, age, religion, personal circumstances, or nature of work; Provided, That, the conscientious objection of a healthcare service provider based on his/her ethical or religious beliefs shall be respected; however, the conscientious objector shall immediately refer the person seeking such care and services to another healthcare service provider within the same facility or one which is conveniently accessible who is willing to provide the requisite information and services; Provided, further, That the person is not in an emergency condition or serious case as defined in RA 8344 penalizing the refusal of hospitals and medical clinics to administer appropriate initial medical treatment and support in emergency and serious cases

Catholic means you take the time to understand why any artificial form of contraception is unacceptable. Not only because some forms of contraception are actually abortifacients, but because a contraceptive mentality goes against our very essence as God’s people. A contraceptive mentality says, “No Lord, not Your will but Mine be done.” A contraceptive mentality says, “No, Lord, I know better than You.” A contraceptive mentality makes the Self its Pope and its God, with no room for humility, correction or obedience. The contraceptive mentality says, “The poor are having too many children too soon.” As mere creations, it is not our office to decide who should bear children and when. Sexuality is a complex thing, yes, and while most of the world knows its mechanics, many remain blind and deaf to its true meaning. It behooves us, then, especially those of us who continue to call ourselves Catholic, to develop a fuller grasp of what God’s design means as manifested in our bodies.

From the Catechism of the Catholic Church:

2370 Periodic continence, that is, the methods of birth regulation based on self-observation and the use of infertile periods, is in conformity with the objective criteria of morality. These methods respect the bodies of the spouses, encourage tenderness between them, and favor the education of an authentic freedom. In contrast, “every action which, whether in anticipation of the conjugal act, or in its accomplishment, or in the development of its natural consequences, proposes, whether as an end or as a means, to render procreation impossible” is intrinsically evil:

Thus the innate language that expresses the total reciprocal self-giving of husband and wife is overlaid, through contraception, by an objectively contradictory language, namely, that of not giving oneself totally to the other. This leads not only to a positive refusal to be open to life but also to a falsification of the inner truth of conjugal love, which is called upon to give itself in personal totality. . . . The difference, both anthropological and moral, between contraception and recourse to the rhythm of the cycle . . . involves in the final analysis two irreconcilable concepts of the human person and of human sexuality.

But, my conscience tells me it’s okay to be pro-RH bill! Dear reader, that only means that your conscience has not been properly formed:

When forming your conscience, please don’t settle for informing it instead. Be informed, yes, by all means. But not by mere information gleaned from sources that do not have your best interests at heart, certainly not your moral or spiritual interests. Allow yourself to be formed what God has revealed to us. By what the Church teaches in the liturgy and in the Catechism. How convenient that our conscience can tell us that whatever we decide is all right and perfectly justified. See how easily we deceive ourselves. “We know better than the Church. After all, we know better than God, don’t we? Why, we can be gods, deciding for ourselves what is good and what is evil.”

You cannot be pro-RH bill, pro-abortion, or pro-contraception and remain a Catholic in good standing. You might think that limits *your choices*, but in reality that should be more freeing for you than confining. Because YOU DO HAVE A CHOICE: You can either believe the lies of those who stand to benefit the most from your moral and religious confusion, or you can choose to trust the wisdom of the Church in this matter and the Words of your Creator. If you don’t understand Scripture and the Catholic faith fully, take heart. Especially this Lenten season, pray and ask the Holy Spirit to guide your learning. Ask Him to open your eyes to the Beauty of God’s Truth. Immerse yourself in Scripture and the Catechism, before saying that you are “merely following your conscience”. But stop stubbornly clinging to a label that has lost most of its meaning for you. A pro-RH bill Catholic deludes no one but himself.

More reading:
The 5 Most Pathetic Words: “I am a Pro-Choice Catholic”
Two Gentlemen on the RH Bill
Against Abortion, But Pro-Choice?
A Pro-Choice Catholic is an Unfaithful Catholic
How I Became Pro-Life
The Truth About Conscience
Ignorance of Faith Can Be Fatal to Individuals and Nations
Catholics Cannot Support RH Bill in Good Conscience

Tagged with: , , , , , , ,
Posted in The Catholic Perspective
10 comments on “No, You Cannot Be Catholic AND Pro-RH Bill
  1. Disciple says:

    Thank you for the quote. And for writing this post! I hope many, many people will read it and think about it deeply and pray for the wisdom to see the wisdom of what Holy Mother Church teaches, which you have presented so well here. God bless you! May you have a blessed Lenten season.


  2. Pearl says:

    This is not the time for us to be Cafeteria Christians. We choose what to believe and what is convenient, which shouldn’t be the case. When Jesus was in the Garden of Gethsemane, when the Father asked him to give His life on the cross, if He made His human choice, acted on His free will, and refused to be obedient, would we have salvation? His anxiety made Him sweat blood but still, He acted upon obedience on ways He cannot fathom, and the Father revealed to Him the greatness of this obedience. If the church is asking us for obedience, to stand up for its teachings, isn’t this the perfect opportunity to do so?

  3. Shane says:

    I disagree , Pearl. That perspective is of atheists. I can understand that you may not be able to grasp our faith , it is as we are aware of the indifferent.

    Thanks to the writer, this is indeed very inspirational.

  4. fred says:

    the welverder tweet – ends with “WTF” – when women talk with a potty mouth, you know much of the culture is going down the toilet

  5. lediskogirl says:

    Well, you can’t be Catholic and taking advantage of women and the convents now, can you?

  6. lediskogirl says:

    *in the convents

  7. lediskogirl says:

    Btw, the “Church Teachings” you obey doesn’t necessarily mean it’s God’s will. When Spain was crusading around the world and ridding it of “barbarians”, including the Philippines, they were following the Church. They said that peaceful surrender will lead to religious tolerance and peaceful cohabitation, but then drove away or killed everyone who didn’t convert to Catholicism. In a way, the Church attacking anyone who supports the RH bill is a variation of this.

    I do not support the RH bill in its entirety, but I agree that the country needs to be educated. They need to have a choice. Whether it’s calendar method or pills, they need to know that there are alternatives to having ten children and seeing half or more die from neglect or poverty.

  8. Jim says:

    This is exactly the thinking (or non-thinking) that the Catholic church seeks to promote. Blind obedience. There is reason gave you a brain. The Catholic Church do not solely represent God’s will. It is the Catholic church’s will. Otherwise, it is God who murdered and pillaged during the crusades and the inquisition. It is also then God who threatened to have Leonardo da Vinci and all the great thinkers during the Renaissance jailed because they say the Earth is round and not the center of the universe. You can see how stupid all this is right now. But now the church is trying to keep people in the dark ages by spreading lies and threatening excommunication with regards to the RH bill. So who made these priests the gatekeepers of heaven? Such arrogance. And these so-called gatekeepers are the same ones who accept bribes and have many mistresses and children. The hypocrisy is staggering. And you want to…..uh….. follow these people without question to be what….a “good catholic”? There is another word for that in the vernacular: Bobo.

  9. jo says:

    The bill was supposed to lower everyone’s headaches especially the Catholic Church.
    Slums are getting bigger. There are more mouths to feed. There is tension between our country and the Chinese. We are getting second-rate hardware for defences. Our government is just beginning to cope up with the losses of the economy. They are also just starting to have a good momentum. We can’t have an overflowing population and expect economic growth when the middle and lower classes have empty stomachs. A large population can become the bane of a country when the resources to feed them is insufficient. We aren’t going anywhere if this madness is to continue.

    try reviewing your past school lessons for the love of god.

    • Disciple says:

      Jo, you seem to have learned your school lessons well. By heart, even. Now learn some truth. The problem most nations are facing now is underpopulation because of rampant abortion and contraception. This has dire consequences for economies. It also has dire consequences for persons directly–both the ones who had their lives cut short and for those responsible.

      We here in the U.S., where I am writing this, have exported our poison all over the world and we marketed that poison as a solution–no, as the solution to every society’s problems. But it is a poison and not a solution of any kind. To have a large and growing economy, one needs a large and growing population. It is absurd to think that a population needs to decrease in order to increase an economy. Look at Europe. Below replacement rate and economies collapsing. The two are directly related.

      Please, for the love of God (capital G), for the love of yourself and your neighbor, review your school lessons and see them for what they are. And if you are Catholic, and even if you aren’t, please review–or read for the first time–what the Church actually teaches about life and life issues and about freedom, too. There’s no way that the RH bill has anything to do with lessening headaches for the Catholic Church. Unless it is meant to lessen Catholics.

      May the Lord strengthen those who remain faithful to Him and grant them grace and graces to help them through this difficult time and help them resist the temptation to adopt a course that has led so many others away from Him. Christ is the Way and the Truth and the Life. Amen.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: